Can you be too generous? Philosophy and Talk stimulus

I’m very fond of the Mr Gumpy books by John Burningham. I love the illustrations and the bizarre happenings. Why does Mr Gumpy let so many people on his boat or in his car? Is he really lovely, or is he a bit daft?!

Concepts include fun, leisure, friendship, welcome, risk, kindness, naivety, community, generosity, stupidity, tolerance, mistakes.

There are many big questions which this story can inspire – for example:

  • Is it possible to be too nice?

  • Should we welcome everybody?

  • Would you rather be very generous or very selfish?

P4C concepts stuck inside a copy of Mr Gumpy's Outing: tolerance, positivity, too nice, generous, generosity, stupidity, risk, choice, equality, happiness, responsibility, personality, character, conflict, conditions, expectations, natural
 
More talk and P4C stimuli
christmas-balls-8449616_1280.jpg
Festive questions

Discussion questions about gifts, feasts and talking snowmen!

Charlies Bar - youtube thumbnail.jpg
Charlie's Bar – P4C stimulus

Why do people sometimes ignore each other?

World Philosophy Day 2024.jpg
Are you ready for World Philosophy Day?

Ideas to get the whole school involved on 21st November

Killing Time At Home - YouTube screengrab.PNG
P4C stimulus – Killing time at home

A chance to think about technology and relationships

Robot cleaner - video thumbnail.PNG
Should we stop cleaning? P4C stimulus

My first encounter with a robot cleaner

beach-1867436_1280.jpg
Animals on beaches – P4C/Talk stimulus

What will your class wonder when they watch this?

Picasso display.jpg
Talking about art – oracy activity

Use talking points to get students thinking and talking about a painting

Hoops of happiness philosophy activity 1.jpg
Hoops of happiness

An activity where participants wonder about the main ingredients for happiness

pets-3715733_1920.jpg
Robot pets – P4C stimulus

Explore concepts including love, technology and what makes something real

mount-fuji-2297961_1280.jpg
Dim the sun? P4C stimulus

A radical proposal for the future

The Big Dreaming - Michael Rosen.jpg
The Big Dreaming – P4C stimulus?

A beautiful book that could make a lovely stimulus for P4C

Portada+Christmas+wonderpondering.png
Christmas wonderings from Wonder Ponder

A free, downloadable, shareable booklet

puppy yoga ITV news screengrab.png
Puppy yoga – P4C stimulus

A stimulus based on a recent news investigation

Musa Motha Britain's Got Talent YouTube thumbnail.PNG
Inspiring P4C stimulus – resilience

Get your pupils thinking and talking about resilience, barriers, beauty and more

freedom-g21920bfaf_1280.jpg
Trash, garbage, potato chips, pants, soccer…

Does it matter if UK children use words and accents from the USA?

Mr Gumpys Outing.jpg
Can you be too generous? Philosophy and Talk stimulus

A fun picture book which can provoke big thinking

Uğur Gallenkus - Parallel Universes of Children.png
P4C stimulus – hard-hitting photo collages

What will your class make of these contrasting images of children’s lives around the world?

besties.jpg
Ban best friends? Talk/Philosophy stimulus

Could preventing some children from having best friends help others?

throwing soup - provocative P4C stimulus - video grab.PNG
Is it okay to throw soup? P4C stimulus

Get your pupils thinking about the rights and wrongs of activism

fluffy angel - P4C stimulus.jpg
Would you clone your pet? P4C stimulus

A stimulus for thinking together about an ethical issue

AI art - children doing philosophy.PNG
Can a robot be an artist? P4C stimulus

Is creativity limited to humans?

path-2291385_1920.jpg
Talking across the curriculum (using Good idea / Bad idea)

Opportunities to use talk structures

Prindle Institute - example.jpg
Fantastic resource site for P4C picture books

Over 200 guides to help you do philosophy with children

HomeTalk - Gifts - excerpt.jpg
HomeTalk – Gifts

Seasonal resources from Dialogue Works’ HomeTalk series

The Dot - Peter H Reynolds - cover.jpg
The Dot – P4C stimulus

A lovely book which will promote thinking about art and self-esteem

Unexpected - P4C stimulus - thumbnail.PNG
Unexpected – a P4C stimulus

What would you do if you found a lot of money?

P4C picture stimuli examples.jpg
Using pictures as your P4C stimulus

Remember that stimuli don’t always have to be stories

Avalanche_on_Everest.jpg
P4C Stimulus – Bravery or Stupidity?

Was filming this a good idea?

chicken-nuggets-gee1841a93_1920.jpg
You are not entitled to your opinion!

Enquiry-based learning is fantastic, but has to be based on facts

Ukraine P4C concepts.jpg
Pictures from Ukraine – P4C stimulus

Creating space for students to discuss challenging current events